The prize no brand wants to win: 2022’s most misleading products28 Nov 2022
Food industry watchdog Foodwatch is asking consumers to vote for 2022’s most misleading product. A high-sugar vitamin water and “artisan” salad made with artificial additives are among the nominees.
Netherlands-based Foodwatch runs an annual Golden Egg competition in which it asks consumers to vote for the most misleading food or drink product of the year. The aim of the tongue-in-cheek award is to draw attention to the misleading – but legal – marketing practices of food and drink manufacturers.
This year, the public can vote for one of three products: an iced tea range made by Dutch retailer Jumbo, a Kellogg’s breakfast cereal, and a ready-to-eat salad made by Dutch retail company Dekamarkt.
“Thousands of products flirt with you with sweet talk marketing and cheating advertisements,” reads the Foodwatch website in Dutch. “Our reporting centre [...] receives daily complaints from disappointed consumers who feel misled in the supermarket. We have been researching the truth behind claims on food packaging for years. Based on this research and the complaints received, [we select] the candidates who, in our opinion, go too far.”
The nominees: Kellogg, Jumbo, and Dekamarkt
Jumbo is up for a nomination with its iced tea range available in three flavours: inner beauty, feel immune, and good energy.
The consumer rights organisation notes that an individual would have to drink over three litres of the product to reach the recommended intake for some vitamins and minerals but each 500-ml pack contains over 18 g of sugar and just 0.07% green tea.
Foodwatch says: “Sugar water with a touch of vitamins where the tea is hard to find! It's amazing how Jumbo manages to make something healthy out of something that isn't so healthy. The Inner Beauty iced tea is said to be good for skin, hair, and nails. But you mainly buy water, sugar, and fructose syrup.”
Kellogg's All-Bran Fruit'n Fibre has been nominated for its "shrinkage inflation" phenomenon. According to Foodwatch, the contents of the pack have been reduced by a quarter but the appearance and size are still the same. The price has dropped only slightly but the price per kilo has increased considerably, it added.
Finally, a potato and free-range egg salad made by Dekamarkt is also nominated. Despite marketing the product as “traditional”, “artisan” and “from grandma’s recipe”, the product contains several ingredients that are unlikely to be found in a grandmother’s kitchen, including sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, and hydrolysed vegetable protein.
Jumbo commits to changing product packaging
A spokesperson for Jumbo told Ingredients Network it planned on changing the product packaging to bring it in line with its recently amended health policy.
“Although the product complies with European laws and regulations, the packaging is changing in the short term. The name of the product will be changed and the health claims will no longer be used. We expect to introduce the product with modified packaging in the first half of 2023.”
“We are aligning the packaging with our health policy. With the nomination, we are accelerating the process,” the spokesperson added.
Kellogg and Dekamarkt did not respond to a request for comment in time for publication of this article.
© iStock/Robert vt Hoenderdaal
Historic winners: Cornbread with cornflour; chocolate spread for babies
Foodwatch’s Golden Egg campaign is now in its 13th year and, in recent years, over 121,000 consumers have cast their vote.
Previous winners include De Kleine Keuken, which scooped up first prize in 2019 for its chocolate spread for babies. The company marketed the product as “good [and] natural for your little one” but Foodwatch noted at the time that the product was made of 69% sugar and fat. “The claim 'from 8 months' is particularly disturbing,” said Foodwatch, adding that the non-profit Nutrition Centre (Voedingscentrum) told it that “parents are being misled by this”.
In 2017, retailer Jumbo won for its 'honest' cornbread, made without corn flour or cornmeal. The bread product is yellow only due to the inclusion of turmeric for colour and contains some corn pieces “for decoration”, slammed Foodwatch.
Coca-Cola, Unilever, Albert Heijn, and Ferrero have also won in the past. To see the full list of past Golden Egg winners, click here.
Winners of the 2022 award will be announced soon, says Foodwatch.
Snack trends, ingredient claims, and plant-based perceptions: Highlights from Fi Europe 2023, part 1
7 Dec 2023
Value-led snacking, sustainability storytelling, and the importance of having a ‘star ingredient’: we asked consumer analysts and market experts at Fi Europe about the trends and innovations that are shaping the food industry.Read more
Confirmed: California bans four ‘toxic’ food additives
10 Oct 2023
Four food additives, including the colouring Red No. 3, will be banned in food in the US state of California over safety concerns, with public health campaigners hoping this will spark a nationwide ban in the coming years.Read more
Advocacy groups condemn EU Commission for backpedalling on animal rights
3 Oct 2023
Amid rumours that the EU may abandon its plans to improve animal welfare in farming and end the use of cages, many stakeholders have condemned this possibility and urged the EU to reconsider.Read more
Poland and Ukraine attempt to resolve grain dispute
29 Sep 2023
Poland and Ukraine have begun talks to try to resolve a dispute regarding the ban on Kyiv’s grain imports that prompted Kyiv to file a lawsuit to the World Trade Organization.Read more
The EU may be set to scrap its sustainability commitments
27 Sep 2023
A speech delivered by President Ursula von der Leyen last week inferred that the EU could be drawing back on its commitments to create a more sustainable and healthier food system.Read more
Industry first: Mosa Meat becomes first cultivated meat startup to gain B Corp certification
11 Sep 2023
A first for the industry, Dutch cultivated meat company Mosa Meat announced that it has received B Corp certification and will soon apply for regulatory approval across the globe.Read more
German supermarket trials climate-centric pricing model
29 Aug 2023
German discount supermarket Penny has trialled increasing product prices to mirror their health and environmental costs.Read more
EPR fee delay spurs concerns over UK’s sustainability commitment
8 Aug 2023
The UK government’s decision to push back the introduction of fees for the Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) due to inflation has raised doubts about whether this sustainability commitment will ever be realised.Read more
Latino-owned food startups tackle climate change
25 Jul 2023
A growing list of Latino-founded food and beverage startups in the US are putting sustainability at the forefront of their businesses for the sake of the planet.Read more
Industry first: The Netherlands approves cultivated meat and seafood tastings
17 Jul 2023
The Netherlands has become the first country in Europe to approve tastings of cultivated meat and seafood in controlled environments, yet there is still a long way to go before widescale commercialisation is achieved.Read more