Brazil sets official definition of ‘whole grain’10 May 2021
Products must contain at least 30% whole grain ingredients to use a whole grain claim in Brazil, under new rules.
According to the legislation, which enters into force on into force on 22 April 2022, cereal-based foods are considered whole grain when the finished product contains at least 30% whole grain ingredients and the quantity of whole ingredients is greater than the quantity of refined ingredients.
Prior to this, there was no legal definition for the use of the term whole grain in Brazil, meaning any food could use the term on product labels, making informed purchasing decisions more difficult for consumers.
The full resolution can be read here (in Portuguese).
Brazil’s food safety regulatory authority, ANVISA, worked with the food industry to draw up the definition with input from civil society groups and a public consultation process.
Manufacturers are permitted to mix refined flour, bran and germ and make a whole grain claim as long as these ingredients are used in quantities that reflect the typical proportion within the intact caryopsis. However, the ingredient list must declare this as ‘whole reconstituted flour’, followed by the common name of the plant species used.
Cereals covered by the resolution include wheat, amaranth, rice, oats, rye, barley, fonio, millet, corn, quinoa, sorghum, teff, and buckwheat. These grains can be processed, such as milled or flaked, as long as the starchy endosperm, bran and germ are present in the same proportion as in the whole caryopsis, the text reads.
Cereal-based foods that do not comply with the whole grain definition cannot use words, symbols, illustrations or any other graphic representations that suggest a whole grain content.
The expert’s view: ‘An important regulatory precedent’
Francisco Jiménez, regulatory affairs adviser at InfoAlimentario, said: “With this new regulation for whole grain cereal-based foods, Brazil set an important regulatory precedent in Latin America, since no country in the region has such requirements like the minimum 30%.”
Jiménez described the regulation, which has been on the cards since 2017, represented a balance between consumer rights, cereal-based product innovation, and marketing practices.
“In my opinion, this minimum amount of whole grain represents the reality of the industrial practices not only in Brazil, but in the global cereal industry, coming along with the innovation processes in such industry,” Jiménez told The Ingredient Network.
“Companies whose products do not meet the criteria to be classified as whole grain, but contain whole grain ingredients have two options: reformulation or to adapt their labels to comply with the new provisions if there is an interest in making something like a whole grain claim.”
A survey carried out in 2016 by Brazilian consumer rights watchdog IDEC found that, five out of 14 cookies making a whole grain claim did not even contain flour or whole grain flour in their formulation. A further six had more refined flour than whole grain flour while three did not contain flour as a main ingredient.
Ana Paula Bortoletto, IDEC nutritionist and research coordinator, said at the time: "As there is no specific legislation, the industry has carte blanche to claim that ultra-processed products are whole grain even when they do not have any type of whole grain, as observed in five evaluated cookies.”
In the US, 100% of the grain kernel’s original bran, germ, and endosperm must be present in their original proportions for an ingredient to count as whole grain.
In Europe, according to the HealthGrain definition, manufacturers may remove up to 2% of the grain’s outer bran layer, which contains the fewest nutrients and can also carry traces of pesticides and mycotoxins.
Rainforest Alliance praises Nescafé for regenerative agriculture efforts
27 Jun 2023
Instant coffee brand Nescafé is supporting coffee farmers to adopt regenerative agricultural practices, according to a recent supply chain assessment by Rainforest Alliance that highlighted “encouraging trends”.Read more
Sustainability commitments lead more LatAm brands to B Corp
19 Jun 2023
A growing number of Latin American brands are becoming B Corp certified as they seek to address consumers’ sustainability concerns, from Colombia’s Luker Chocolate to Brazil’s Naveia and B.You Açaí.Read more
Tea brands accused of human rights abuses
9 Jun 2023
Multinational companies with tea brands, like Unilever, Starbucks and Tetley, have been linked to dozens of counts of human rights abuse in their supply chains from last year alone, according to a recent report from the Business and Human Rights Resour...Read more
New Zealand mānuka honey producers lose battle to trademark product
7 Jun 2023
New Zealand’s Intellectual Property Office (IPO) has ruled that mānuka honey cannot be trademarked, which means that neighbouring Australian producers can use the valuable name.Read more
Singapore’s Nutri Grade label spurs beverage reformulation
24 May 2023
Nearly six months after becoming mandatory for drinks, Singapore’s Nutri-Grade front-of-pack label is encouraging some beverage brands to reduce sugar and saturated fat content.Read more
US introduces Food Labeling Modernization Act
23 May 2023
Amid calls for better food integrity and safety, the US Congress has proposed a bill for clearer nutritional information and accurate labelling claims.Read more
EFSA’s proposed BPA limits may be ‘totally unrealistic’
2 May 2023
The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) has proposed limits for Bisphenol A – a chemical known to be harmful to health – that are 20,000 times lower than before, but they may be “totally unrealistic” for the food industry to meet, says one food safet...Read more
US-Mexico trade tensions rise over Mexico’s GM import ban
17 Apr 2023
As trade tensions rise between Mexico and the US over a Mexican ban on imports of genetically modified (GM) corn, Mexican food safety authorities have announced plans to investigate the presence of GM corn in the country’s tortillas and the risk of eat...Read more
SAFE raises concerns over EU directive to avoid false green claims
5 Apr 2023
Following the release of the European Commission’s proposal to avoid false and misleading green claims, Safe Food Advocacy Europe (SAFE) is calling for updates to prevent consumer confusion and exploitation.Read more
Confectionery firm fined €10k for misleading Nutri-Score use
30 Mar 2023
Italy’s Competition and Market Authority (AGCM) has fined Vivil A. Muller (Vivil) €10,000 due to its misleading use of the Nutri-Score system to indicate the healthiness of its confectionary.Read more