In Ireland, Subway’s sandwich rolls are not legally bread13 Oct 2020
The Irish Supreme Court ruled that Subway bread is not legally considered as such. Instead, its sugar content, which is five times above what Irish law specifies as the acceptable threshold for bread, lands the company’s sandwich rolls in the confectionery category. The ruling was a result of a tax dispute case.
This finding by Ireland’s highest court requires Bookfinders Ltd., an Irish Subway franchise, to pay a value-added tax (VAT) on its sandwiches. Sweets and pastries are not considered an essential food under Irish law and are, therefore, subject to a value-added tax of 13.5 percent under Ireland’s VAT Act of 1972. “Staple foods,” like bread, are not subject to this tax. However, to qualify as a staple product, the Irish government defines bread as a product where “fat, sugar and bread improver, subject to the limitation that the weight of any ingredient specified in this subclause shall not exceed 2 percent of the weight of flour included in the dough.”
In the judgment, the court ruled, "There is no dispute that the bread supplied by Subway in its heated sandwiches has a sugar content of 10% of the weight of the flour included in the dough, and thus exceeds the 2% specified."
Subway maintains that its bread is only bread, and MarketWatch reported that the company is currently reviewing the tax ruling.
This latest ruling from the Irish Supreme Court was heard on appeal after the case meandered through four appellate courts over 14 years where it was heard and then subsequently dismissed in each case. Subway’s Galway-based franchisee sued the Irish taxing authorities for a refund of VAT paid between 2004 and 2005. The company argued that its heated sandwiches, coffees and teas were eligible for 0% VAT. The composite VAT rate they paid was 9.2%.
Subway is not unfamiliar with controversy. The company came under scrutiny in 2014 when reports surfaced that its bread was baked with a chemical used in yoga mats. In response, the company removed the ingredient and changed the recipe. Depending on whether the company accepts the ruling from the country's highest court, it could consider another reformulation of its sandwich rolls in order to qualify under the legally defined definition for bread.
Canada rolls out new front-of-pack ‘magnifying glass’ label for high salt, sugar and fat foods
26 Jul 2022
Canadian authorities have launched a new front-of-package nutrition label designed to help shoppers make more informed product selections as they purchase groceries by highlighting foods high in specific ‘unhealthy’ nutrients.Read more
Kids’ breakfast products in the US are more sugary than some popular desserts
18 Jul 2022
School meal breakfast programmes in the US are buying breakfast products with "as much or more" added sugars as some popular desserts, according to the non-profit Center for Science in the Public Interest (CSPI).Read more
Traffic light label may the best fit for front-of-pack labelling in China
13 Jul 2022
Front-of-pack labels that utilize multiple traffic lights for specific nutrients are best understood and preferred by a wide variety of Chinese shoppers, according to a recent study.Read more
Kellogg’s loses UK legal case against high-sugar cereal rules
11 Jul 2022
US cereal manufacturer Kellogg has lost a UK High Court case that challenged regulations intended to restrict the promotion of high-sugar breakfast cereals in supermarkets.Read more
Sustainable behaviours must begin to resonate with consumers too
7 Jul 2022
Food producers, brand owners, retailers and governments must work together to help drive consumers towards more sustainable behaviours, experts warn.Read more
Parmesan partnership to put ‘blockchain ready’ digital chip on all cheese wheels
29 Jun 2022
A new line of food-safe and secure digital labels on each Parmigiano Reggiano cheese wheel will deliver previously unseen levels of traceability, product control, and quality assurance, says the Consorzio del Parmigiano Reggiano (CFPR).Read more
New EU mineral oil limits an ‘important step for food safety’
23 Jun 2022
The EU’s decision to restrict aromatic mineral oils (MOAH) in food products has been hailed as an important step in food safety and consumer protection but consumer organisation, Foodwatch, is calling for binding regulation to go one step further.Read more
NutriScore logo could help young people make healthier food choices – but more awareness is needed
22 Jun 2022
The European Nutri-Score labelling system can help young people make healthier food choices, according to a Spanish study – but one third still do not know what the label indicates.Read more
Clear and accurate precautionary allergen labelling is vitally important, says regulatory expert
17 Jun 2022
As the UK’s Food Standards Agency looks to standardise allergen label wording, it is “vitally important” that food businesses provide consumers with clear and accurate precautionary information about potential unintended allergens in ...Read more
Monterey Mushrooms gets EU approval for vitamin D-rich mushroom powder
16 Jun 2022
Monterey Mushrooms’ vitamin D-rich mushroom powder, produced using ultraviolet (UV) to boost the nutrient content, can be sold in the EU, following novel food approval from the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA).Read more
Are you a supplier?
Here's what we can do for you
- Generate quality leads for your business
- Stay visible for 365 days of the year
- Receive product inquiries and respond to meeting requests directly
- Improve company online presence through Search Engine Optimisation