Reformulating with Protein

28 Oct 2014

At Food ingredients Europe (FiE) 2013 in Frankfurt, one of the big trends predicted for 2014 was protein. That was until, of course, sugar hit the headlines in January! However, these two aspects of formulation can, in fact, go hand-in-hand. There are a number of  issues with the very well-publicised, and confrontational, sugar debate; namely, […]

Reformulating with Protein

At Food ingredients Europe (FiE) 2013 in Frankfurt, one of the big trends predicted for 2014 was protein. That was until, of course, sugar hit the headlines in January!

However, these two aspects of formulation can, in fact, go hand-in-hand. There are a number of  issues with the very well-publicised, and confrontational, sugar debate; namely, it is questionable to demonise a single ingredient, since dietary-related health issues are more likely rooted in more multi-dimensional factors such as calorie intake as a whole and lifestyle choice. With this in mind, it is fair to suggest that sugar intake – and fat, for that matter – may indeed be too high. However, it is quite possibly more useful and constructive to suggest that protein and fibre intake are, in fact, too low and need to be increased.

The focus on sugar is in danger of making the same mistake that the fat lobby made 30 years ago.  Demonisation of a single ingredient encourages a direct replacement of that single ingredient. Before, fat content and calories were the issue, and in some cases sugar was deemed a suitable alternative as it maintained a high level of palatability; provided adequate structural alternatives; and reduced the calorie content (1g sugar delivers 3.75Kcal compared to the 9Kcal/g gained from fat).

The object of the exercise was therefore successfully met: lower fat, lower calories. However, some years later as science understood more about the role of sugar on health, and obesity increasingly became an issue, the success of the reformulation activity was, and has been, rightly questioned.

The future of dietary-led health and wellbeing must be driven by a more holistic approach to reformulation and development, and protein is an essential building block within that landscape. There has been a lot of work on protein in recent years – hence the rise of many new functional food and drink offerings – and it is these very ingredients that are providing innovative solutions to the headline-grabbing agendas.

A particularly interesting branch of research into proteins centres on their modification into micro-particles in such a way that they behave in a similar way to fats in a food matrix (Chung et al., 2014).   The research into micro-particulated proteins by Herriot Watt University is being commercialised by Nandi Proteins, and products are not far from the shelves. With protein being 4Kcal/g, it will provide a suitable fat and calorie reducing option that isn’t sugar, and can contribute to a more holistic and balanced approach to reformulation.  Whilst this technology is not strictly new, with Simplesse (also a micro-particulated whey protein) having been available for some years, this continued focus and innovation in protein technology is a positive step.

A particular functionality where protein – namely whey protein – could become an exciting part of the reformulation strategy relates to its purported impact on satiety. However, the nutrition and health claims submission for satiety and weight management was rejected (EFSA ,2010) and more recent studies by Leatherhead Food Research (2013) found that there was still insufficient data available to consider a successful resubmission of this dossier. Despite this, studies are ongoing as it is widely believed that protein has a fundamental role in the feeling of fullness. Leidy et al., (2013) found that a protein-rich breakfast increased satiation and helped control food intake in a population of overweight girls. So, to make intelligent reformulation changes that not only reduce calories, potentially replace fat and sugar, re-balance protein, and in doing so you will reduce the desire to overindulge; this has to be a choice worth considering.

 

 

References

 

  • Chung, C., Degner, B., McClements, D. J. (2014) Reduced calorie emulsion-based foods: Protein microparticles and dietary fiber as fat replacers. Food Research International, 64, pp. 664-676.
  • The European Food Safety Authority. Scientific Opinion on the substantiation of health claims related to protein and increase in satiety leading to a reduction in energy intake (ID 414, 616, 730), contribution to the maintenance or achievement of a normal body weight (ID 414, 616, 730), maintenance of normal bone (ID 416) and growth or maintenance of muscle mass (ID 415, 417, 593, 594, 595, 715) pursuant to Article 13(1) of Regulation (EC) No 1924/2006. Website accessed on 23/10/2014:   http://www.efsa.europa.eu/en/efsajournal/doc/1811.pdf
  • Hull, S., Diaz-Toledo, C., Re., R. (2014) Submission of a Health Claim Dossier to EFSA (Leatherhead Food Research Members Research Report 963). Leatherhead, Surrey: Leatherhead Food Research.
  • Leidy, H. J., Ortinau, L. C., Douglas, S. M., Hoertel, H. A. (2013) Beneficial effects of a higher-protein breakfast on the appetitive, hormonal, and neural signals controlling energy intake regulation in overweight/obese, “breakfast-skipping,” late-adolescent girls. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 97(4), pp. 677-688.

Related tags

Blogs New

Related news

What role do omega-3s play in sports nutrition?

What role do omega-3s play in sports nutrition?

10 Jul 2018

Omega-3 fatty acids have increasingly become part of athletes’ nutritional regime over the past few years but research supporting their role in sports nutrition is still in its early stages.

Read more 
Could nature-identical ingredients damage the natural sweeteners market?

Could nature-identical ingredients damage the natural sweeteners market?

4 Jul 2018

Natural sweeteners are a major target for companies looking to make nature-identical food ingredients, but if they are produced in a lab rather than extracted from a plant, will consumers accept them as natural?

Read more 
How does honey compare to sugar?

How does honey compare to sugar?

27 Jun 2018

Sugar use is down and honey use is up as manufacturers look for natural sweetening alternatives – but does honey live up to the hype?

Read more 
Fruit and vegetable powders add clean label nutrition, colour and flavour

Fruit and vegetable powders add clean label nutrition, colour and flavour

25 Jun 2018

Fruit and vegetable powders are appearing in a range of foods and drinks to improve their flavour, colour, nutrition and texture, driven by the trend toward whole foods and consumer desire to boost fruit and vegetable consumption.

Read more 
What are the smartest botanical ingredients for brain health?

What are the smartest botanical ingredients for brain health?

20 Jun 2018

As the population ages, botanical ingredients to maintain and improve cognitive health are on the rise. What are they, and what evidence is there to support their claims?

Read more 
Turning a spotlight on healthy fats and oils

Turning a spotlight on healthy fats and oils

19 Jun 2018

European food manufacturers have been turning to healthier oils and fats – but there is often a trade-off to be made, balancing their benefits in terms of flavour and health with how easy they are to work with.

Read more 
Beyond ingredients: Food processing as a tool for cleaner labels

Beyond ingredients: Food processing as a tool for cleaner labels

12 Jun 2018

Ingredients come first when companies think about developing clean label foods and drinks, but certain processing technologies also should be considered part of the clean label toolbox.

Read more 
Plant-based eating boosts European walnut demand

Plant-based eating boosts European walnut demand

12 Jun 2018

The current trend toward plant-based diets and wholesome, natural ingredients has led to increased European demand for walnuts, as consumers have become more aware of their health benefits.

Read more 
Europeans embrace a new wave of seaweed ingredients

Europeans embrace a new wave of seaweed ingredients

6 Jun 2018

Seaweed ingredients are on the rise, set to appear in a wide range of new products in Europe in the coming years – far beyond the traditional sushi and miso soup.

Read more 
How clean label ingredients affect packaging

How clean label ingredients affect packaging

28 May 2018

When companies consider ‘cleaning up’ their product labels, they often focus primarily on how to remove or replace certain ingredients – but they should also consider implications for product packaging.

Read more